I have 2 domain controllers, both have DNS role installed, both seem to be working correctly (i.e. client records are added and are replicated to both servers.) I have 1 zone, it is active directory-integrated primary. Both servers are set to not zone
transfer (per technet.microsoft.com/en-us/library/cc781340(v=ws.10).aspx ) and neither have any secondary servers defined.
Domain controller 1 = Elrond (10.36.0.6), 2008R2
Domain Controller 2 = Thorin (10.36.0.38), 2012
Despite no actual difficulties with clients, I suspect I have a problem because of 2 things:
1) BPA on Thorin (but not on Elrond) shows "Warning DNS: Zone TrustAnchors secondary server 10.36.0.6 should respond to queries for this zone"
2) While doing some testing, I ran across the recommendation to try nslookup. When I ran it in an elevated prompt from Thorin I received:
C:\Windows\system32>nslookup
Default Server: elrond.lynden.k12.wa.us
Address: 10.36.0.6
> server elrond
Default Server: elrond.lynden.k12.wa.us
Address: 10.36.0.6
> ls lynden.k12.wa.us
[elrond.lynden.k12.wa.us]
*** Can't list domain lynden.k12.wa.us: Query refused
The DNS server refused to transfer the zone lynden.k12.wa.us to your computer. I
f this
is incorrect, check the zone transfer security settings for lynden.k12.wa.us on
the DNS
server at IP address 10.36.0.6.
And when run from Elrond, I get the same message about Thorin refusing:
C:\Windows\system32>nslookup
Default Server: thorin.lynden.k12.wa.us
Address: 10.36.0.38
> server thorin
Default Server: thorin.lynden.k12.wa.us
Address: 10.36.0.38
> ls lynden.k12.wa.us
[thorin.lynden.k12.wa.us]
*** Can't list domain lynden.k12.wa.us: Query refused
The DNS server refused to transfer the zone lynden.k12.wa.us to your co
f this
is incorrect, check the zone transfer security settings for lynden.k12.
the DNS
server at IP address 10.36.0.38
My reading from the TechNet article is that zone transfers should not be enabled since AD already handles that functionality. Does that mean this error is really ok? it seems strange.